The Best Baking Sheets (Review) in 2019
Every cook knows that, as talented as we may be at whipping together a solid mixture, the end result always comes down to the tools at our disposal. That’s why it’s always so disappointing when we work our behinds off, only for our baking sheets to let us down and burn the bottom of our cakes or attach themselves to food so vehemently that we need to scrub them down, afterwards.
The best baking sheets will never let you down and can, in fact, improve your cooking game exponentially. That’s why we’ve scoured the internet to bring you the best cookie sheets on the market. These baking trays will never let you down at the last second and you won’t find yourself sweating into your sink as you try to scrub away a day’s work.
Better still, we’ve once again given you everything you need to know about what to look for in a baking sheet and what makes our Top Picks the best baking trays on the market, today. So, read on and kick up your cooking a notch with our buying guide and FAQ.
The Best Baking Sheet
Hitting the coveted top spot of our Top Picks is the Commercial Baker’s Big Sheet from Nordic Ware. This baking tray is extremely large, so be aware that it may not be suitable for those who have a slimline oven. For everyone else, this is the best baking sheet on the market, today.
As well as being extremely highly rated by customers, who loved how easily their baked goods could be removed from the tray once they had finished cooking, these trays are made with reinforced rims and galvanized steel. This allows them to be used time and time again without the wear and tear you might notice in other, cheaper options.
There’s no warping and no danger of uneven cooking either, as the material allows for an even spread of heat during use. The only drawback to this item is that it is handwash only- but we can forgive Nordic Ware for this, when you consider the many benefits it brings!
Made in the USA
Hand wash only
Reinforced rims with galvanized steel
A baking sheet and wire rack combination that takes care of every cooking and baking need you could possibly have, this quarter-sized aluminum cookie pan from Kitchenatics is the best baking tray on the market for those who enjoy a little versatility in their baking sheet.
The tight grid pattern of the wire rack with regular, 1-inch stands means there’s no risk of sagging or breaking over time- even with regular use. It fits perfectly into the baking sheet and allows for any juices or loose debris to be caught without issue during cooking, too. Meanwhile, the baking tray itself is made of a heavy-duty aluminum and perfect for regular baking.
Cooling rack and sheet combination
Tight grid pattern on the rack to avoid sagging and breaks
Very durable construction and material
This set of three, non-stick cookie sheet from Rachael Ray’s Bakeware collection is a great choice if you’re looking for a set of rimmed baking sheets. The high rims are ideal for brownies, while the extra wide handles are home to grips, to make fetching and placing your cookies sheets all the easier- meaning you’re less likely to get burned hands while cooking.
The pans themselves are made from a heavy-duty steel which resists warping and you even get the added benefit of knowing that a percentage of the profits are shared with Rachael’s non-profit, Yum-O!
Set of three, steel trays
Added silicone grip on the handles
Warp resistant material with non-stick coating
Our first option of the kind, this 2-pack of cookie sheets from AirBake is the best rimless baking tray for those who love to bake cookies and are after quick, tasty results from their baking sheet. Made from 100% aluminum, these trays come with a gentle rise on one side, to make it easier to place and remove the trays from the oven, while still retaining the non-rimmed benefits of these cookie sheets.
10-year warranty included
Prevents overheating on the top shelf
No risk of rust
If you already have your perfect baking sheet but are looking for a cooking and cooling wire rack to fit your half sheet pan, this option from Ultra Cuisine should be your first stop. Made with a very high-quality stainless steel that is both warp and rust resistant, this rack has been made to fit both your baking and cooking needs.
With over 2,500 5-star ratings from users, you can be sure that this is a fantastic wire rack that works not only in your oven but- thanks to its resistance to heat even up to 575 degrees- can be used during BBQ season, too. The only drawback is that it doesn’t come with it’s own baking sheet to the same specification.
Extra strong wire grid for both baking and cooling
Made with professional-grade steel
Perfect for all kinds of cooking and baking
A complete set that covers all of your baking needs, this is the ideal choice for those who love to bake but want to have a matching set with matching abilities to heat and cook in your oven. It’s also the best choice of baking sets if you’re looking to stock a new home and take your baking to the next level.
The entire set is made from carbon steel and has a non-stick coating. They are also ovenproof up to 500 degrees. However, they aren’t dishwasher safe as this is likely to rub the non-stick coating off and damage your set.
Complete set for all your baking needs
Non-stick coating across the set
Hand wash only
Coming as a set of three cookie sheets, these non-stick, steel options are perfect for those who want a size to meet every cooking or baking need you might have in your kitchen. This is an updated design of a previously popular choice from Good Cook, who have improved the durability and wear of their baking sheets to better suit your needs.
These baking sheets come at an incredible price and, even better, they add further value with a lifetime exchange guarantee. Should your cookie sheets wear out or warp, Good Cook will exchange your old for new!
Set of three non-stick cookie sheets
Comes with a lifetime exchange guarantee
New design comes with increased durability
From the makers of USA Pan, comes a baking pan and wire rack combination that is proving just as popular with users as the rest of their much-loved products. These pans have a unique ability in that their surface is corrugated to improve the overall heat dispersion while in your oven, resulting in more efficient cooking.
They have also gone above an beyond to provide a patented non-stick coating that is PTFE, BPA and PFOA-free- meaning no nasty chemicals, all while you still enjoy your non-stick surface and the ease that this brings with it.
Set includes wire rack and baking tray
Baking tray surface is corrugated for more efficient cooking
Another great set of bakeware pieces, which are best suited to new users and those who have just moved home and want a complete, brand new set of bakeware. This particular choice is made from a heavy-gauge steel, so don’t expect your light, fluffy cookies from this choice- however, you will still get a series of awesome baked goods if you lower your oven temperature and allow for a little extra time.
The biggest benefit here is that this bakeware set is completely dishwasher-safe, so clean-up time is next to nothing when compared to some of the others on our list.
Heavy gauge steel won’t warp during use
Six piece set that includes every cookware item you need for your baking needs
Made with artificial coatings or treatments, this is a great choice if you’re looking for a wire rack and tray combination without having to risk any exposure of sensitivities or allergies to chemicals. These are a combination of simple but successful, with customer attesting to how well this baking sheet cooks and how efficiently the food can be removed from the surface.
In terms of convenience, the rack and tray work together perfectly, but you should be aware that, while the rack is made of stainless steel and completely dishwasher safe, the tray itself should be hand-washed only.
Set includes wire rack and baking sheet
Rack is dishwasher-safe, while the baking sheet is hand-wash only
No artificial coatings or treatments
Another great option from USA Pan, this half sheet pan option comes in a set of two and holds some of the best features that USA Pan have to offer. In particular, the corrugated surface makes for efficient and even cooking, while their patented non-stick coating means there is no risk of any exposure to chemicals- perfect for those with sensitivities or allergies.
Made from a heavy-duty, commercial-grade aluminized steel, these pans will never warp or fall out of shape- especially with the reinforced, steel wire rim which further prevents any risk of warping over time.
Set of two half sheet baking trays
Corrugated base for efficient and even cooking
Uses patented non-stick coating
OXO are becoming increasingly popular with their homeware and cookware and for good reason- especially when they keep bringing out new designs that hold their own as standalone items. For example, these half sheet baking trays are made with a ceramic, two-layer coating that is PFOA-free and works brilliantly at distributing heat during cooking.
Meanwhile, the textured pattern along the bottom surface of the baking tray allows for ideal heat distribution and creates a non-stick surface that is perfect for regular bakers and chefs. Even better, this is item is completely dishwasher-safe, making it the best baking tray for those who want minimal clean-up after they’re done with their baking.
Ceramic-reinforced, dual-layered coating
Textured pattern along the base causes efficient cooking and a non-stick quality
Another great option that has utilized the benefits of a textured surface, this two-piece set from Circulon has created a great choice using it’s namesake by providing a series of circle patterns along the base to ensure that food will both cook evenly and be separated easily.
This PFOA-free carbon steel offering comes with a limited lifetime warranty, although the positive reviews suggest that any need for this is unlikely. Meanwhile, the set is also dishwasher safe, so perfect for those of us who prefer to stick our dirty dishes in the machine and go.
Include a limited lifetime warranty
Non-stick coating and raised circles make removing and cleaning extra easy
If you have a huge party coming up, have to cater for an event, got suckered into providing plenty of baked goods for friends and family or simply really hate the idea of cleaning up, these disposable, recyclable aluminum foil baking sheets are a fantastic choice for you.
Available as a set of 15, these are perfect for parties and events, without sacrificing your cooking and baking quality thanks to the even distribution of heat these baking sheets provide. You might not get the same quality as the more permanent options- but they’re still a fantastic choice and easily the best disposable baking sheets available on the market, today.
Disposable, recyclable foil sheets
Very sturdy for foil baking sheets
Cooks and bakes evenly
Our final option is another rimless baking sheet that allows for fantastic distribution of heat around your oven and lets you get to your baked goods quickly and easily. Made with a heavy gauge aluminum, this sheet is raised on one end for easier removable and has been manufactured in an NSF-certified facility in the USA, from start to finish.
Despite being a handwash only item, customers have fallen in love with the longevity and overall effectiveness of this simple choice which, in at least one review, has lasted over 9 years with constant use!
Rimless cookie sheet
Hand wash only
Best Baking Sheets Buying Guide & FAQ
What to Look for in a Cookie Sheet
The size of your baking pan will make a difference in terms of how much you can fit onto your sheet. If you’re looking to do batch cooking, getting a larger baking pan might seem like the best idea- but you should be wary of accidentally picking up a commercial-sized sheet that will be too big for your oven.
If you have a slimmer oven or want to cook more than one thing at once, a good way around this is to purchase a set of two half sheet pan. Each half sheet pan will be able to sit alongside each other or on different levels of your oven. Just be sure that the smells emanating from the baking food on each sheet don’t interact with each other- if you’re going to be making cookies and chicken at the same time, it might be best to wait until the oven has handled the aroma before popping your next baking sheet of goods in.
The right material can make a huge difference in the final result of your cooking and baking. Having a baking sheet that is made from a decent material will cause your food to cook evenly, without burning and can also make a huge difference in clean-up time, too.
For example, a stainless steel cookie sheet is a good option as they are completely inert and are generally very hard-wearing options that can handle a lot of use, over time. That said, there are still better options out there which are better at conducting heat evenly and cooking more efficiently.
Aluminum is a popular choice- and for good reason. Apart from copper, there is no better conductor for heat in common household cookware. It is unlikely to scuff and is generally a very durable option. Unfortunately, they’re not great in the dishwasher as this can damage the material.
Carbon steel is another popular option but, unfortunately, these are best left for bakers of bread goods, as the reluctance to conduct heat can make these options much slower than others- not ideal for cookies who usually require quicker times in the oven. That said, if you have a convection oven, you would be unlikely to notice any hot spots, so do consider your oven type when buying your carbon steel baking sheets, too.
- Rimmed or Non-Rimmed
We discuss the impact that each of these options have in more detail, below. Suffice to say that having a rim on your cookie sheet makes a surprising amount of difference when it comes to your cooking and baking requirements.
With so much competition online, it really can be the features that make all the difference when it comes to which baking sheet you’re thinking of buying. While they may not be fundamental to their use in a cooking capacity, these features can make your cooking go from average to perfect, or even help with how convenient it is to use your new items.
- Dishwasher Safe
Having your new cooking trays be dishwasher-safe can make it so much easier to clean up after a hard day of baking. Not all sheets are suitable for use in a dishwasher, however, so be sure to check this before buying. You should also be aware that even dishwasher-safe options are more likely to wear down at a much faster rate, if they’re always cleaned these way.
- Non-stick coating
A non-stick coating can make your life much easier when it comes to moving your goods, once cooked, as you won’t need to angle a spatula beneath your food in a desperate attempt to separate the great love between your food and the baking sheet. Having a non-stick option means that your baking tray has been coated in a thin layer of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) or Teflon, which provide a barrier between the food and the metal. Those that are sensitive to chemical should steer clear of these, however, as they can give off a gas when heated to high temperatures.
If you want a non-stick coating but found a choice you love but doesn’t provide this, you can always purchase non-stick baking mats instead- or simply go old school, using greaseproof paper or a thin layer of butter and flour. Finally, you can also check out a more appropriate design (see below) which can help provide a non-stick base.
Some of the more modern choices in baking sheets have taken the design of these trays to the next level by integrating useful features into the very build of the sheets. For example, many of the options above use raised, corrugated or shaped bases which help to distribute the heat more effectively, leading to more efficient cooking.
Having the regular gaps caused by these inlaid designs also helps to provide more of a non-stick surface than the traditional, flat baking trays which often cause the cookies or similar baked goods to stick to the surface of the tray. These gaps allow air to travel under the cooked food, making it much easier to lift from the tray itself.
- Mixed Sets
You might notice that some of the Top Picks we’ve chosen come with more than just your basic baking sheets. These are perfect for new homes, new starters and keen hobbyists who are looking to have every base covered. The sets of baking sheets and full collections may cost a little more but we can assure you that these are totally worth it, if you’re looking to really get into your cooking and baking, especially as the overall cost is much lower than buying these separately.
Any reviews are key, when buying only- but especially when it comes to regular-use items such as baking sheets. Check out the baking tray reviews before buying to see if there is anything you should be aware of, such as poor customer service or flimsy materials which bend and warp in the oven.
With reviews, you can be sure that, if there are any issues, these will be picked up on and fed back to the internet as quick as a flash. Thus, those items that are highly rated are also sure to be big hits, with plenty of users who have tried and tested your new item ahead of time.
Rìmmed VS. Non-Rimmed Cookie Sheets
The rimmed baking sheet vs non-rimmed cookie sheets has raged ever since The Joy of Cooking claimed that rimless baking sheets are better at providing even cooking and therefore create a much higher quality cookie. Since then, the science behind the theory has been tested thoroughly and the following were found:
- When looking at how evenly each batch of cookies is baked when using rimmed vs. rimless baking trays, there is little to no difference. Especially when using modern, rimmed baking sheets that already have an excellent capacity to conduct heat and spread heat evenly.
- Cookies that are baked on rimless cooking trays are ready much faster- well before those that were baked on trays with rims.
This is because, as the hot air rises, the lack of the rim on these non-rimmed cookie sheets allow the heat to wash over the cookies at a much faster rate than baking sheets with rims. Rimmed cookie sheets in an oven take longer for a full circulation of heat over the baking sheets themselves, which results in a longer cooking time overall.
Naturally, this is great if you’re only ever looking at baking cookies or similar. But, if you’re after a baking sheet that will work for savory foods or even baked goods like brownies, there’s no need to rush out right away and get yourself a non-rimmed baking tray. It’s much more important to purchase a tray that works for your needs!
So, should you ever decide to purchase a baking sheet purely for cookies or similar baked goods, choosing a rimless option will allow you to cut down on overall cooking time- ideal if you’re in a rush. Naturally, if you have a rimmed baking sheet, you can simply wait a little longer for the cookies to be cooked to the same level.
Our Top Pick
Our Top Pick was easily scooped up by the Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker's Big Sheet from Nordic Ware, who have produced a fantastic option for many bakers and cooks. This is a baking tray that can stand the test of time with a lifetime of durability and fantastic space that allows baking without the mess or fuss of a hefty clean-up.
Completed formed from whole aluminum and made- from start to finish- in the USA, this non-stick pan is ideal for those who are both hobbyist and regular bakers, meaning it easily climbs up the ranks to hit Our Top Pick position.