As it is the season for homemade pies, cookies and desserts that keep us warm inside, we have compiled for you here a list of the best pie crust cutters which will help take your holiday pastries to the next level. We present to you a range of products that are all unique in their own way; from the material used, to the shapes produced. They all come from reputable brands that have created products that customers have used and enjoyed which also range in different prices. No doubt, these decorative pie crust cutters, will help impress your friends and family by adding the beauty to already great tasting foods.
The Best Pie Crust Cutter
Our best choice pie crust cutter from the brand Mrs. Anderson assures buyers of a high-quality product that brings the fun to baking and designing. Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters can be used to cut out mini shapes out of dough, create decorative pie crust and make all kinds of pastries. It comes with a spring attachment, so that after being pushed down, it springs right back up, making it super easy and fun to use.
This package comes with four different shapes including an apple, cherry, leaf and heart. No doubt, most customers love using this product especially over the holidays, claiming that it is easy to use, brings out perfect shapes and most importantly, clean up is relatively easy. Overall, these cutters can be used for all your baking needs, from cakes, pies and cookies.
Made from polypropylene
Spring action to emboss design
Set of 4 different shapes
- Brand Mrs. Anderson’s Baking
- Weight 4 ounces
The Nordic Ware Lattice & Hearts Pie Top Cutter might just be the key for making the perfect pie. This single plastic cutter is designed to be reversible, which means, it can be turned inside out to produce a new shape. With this pie cutter you can create ornate lattice weave and hearts on your pie in just a short three step process. Roll out your dough, lay the dough over the cutter and press a rolling pin over the dough, but don’t forget to add a little flower to the cutter to avoid any stickiness. Perfect shapes will be created every time. We can vouch for this lattice pie crust cutter; it is easy to use, easy to wash, the perfect size and will cut out the desired shapes in a matter of seconds.
Creates 2 different shapes
Made of food safe plastic
Easy to wash
- BrandNordic Ware
- Weight 11.2 ounces
From the brand Tovolo comes this modern spin on a pie dough cutter. Thanks to it’s in-built measuring system, this Tovolo Precision Pie Crust Cutter is meant to measure your pie crust before cutting. It is also equipped with a cutting guide, a magnet to hold the plastic blade in place and four different cutters to design the edge of your pie with. This is a device that takes, precision, perfection and attractive designs into account.
The brand Tovolo dedicates its time to making kitchen products as practical and fun as possible and this device is no different. What’s more, the pie crust cutter comes highly rated and recommended by those who have used it, as it serves its purpose well and is created from high quality material that will last in your kitchen for as long as you intend to make pies.
Measures and cuts pie crust
For 2”-14″ baking dishes
Includes 4 different cutters
Made from BPA free material
- Model 81-19546C
- Weight 2.88 ounces
This eleven piece pie cutting and decorating kit from Fox Run, is designed to keep your pie designs impressive and fresh, and also to last a long time in your kitchen. The Fox Run 4391 Pie Decorating Kit comes with one roller, four pattern wheels and six cutters, which achieve shapes such as hearts, leaves, acorns, trees and more. And if you’re looking for variety, this may be the product for you.
The Fox Run 4391 Pie Decorating Kit pieces are made of stiff plastic that are durable and should hand wash easily. This product has been appreciated for being high quality; it is stiff enough to get the job done but still very lightweight, so it is not too much of a hassle and generally a fun product to add to your kitchen.
Made of durable plastic
Includes 1 roller and 4 pattern wheels
Can be used for pie edges and cutting out shapes
11 piece package
- BrandFox Run
- Weight 3.2 ounces
If you’re looking for a more traditional product then the Mini Cookie Cutter Set from the brand Merry Bird will have you covered. This set comes as the most affordable product on our list, but it takes the prize for our best value item because despite its price it is still equipped with up to twelve tin cutters, giving you both variety and value. What’s more, the shapes included with this product include, rain drop, heart, star and flower just to name a few. And because it is made with stainless steel, these decorative pie crust cutters are incredibly easy to clean and will not have your dough sticking to them. Furthermore, this set can also be used for a range of deserts and you can get as creative as you want; as long as a shape can be cut of a desert, the Mini Cookie Cutter Set will do the job.
Set of 12 tin cutters
Made with stainless steel
Can be used for pies and cookies
- BrandMERRY BIRD
- Weight 3.2 ounces
The Fox Run 4779 Lattice Pie Top Cutter will give your pie a professional finish, with its well carved lattice shapes. This clean and easy device is a great addition to your kitchen; it produces a great shape, is easy to use and also easy to clean. Made with polystyrene plastic this lattice pie cutter, rest assured it is safe and will last a lifetime in your home. We love this product for the simple reason that it does the job perfectly and can be cleaned fairly quickly. Whether bought as a gift or for your own kitchen, this is one purchase that you will not regret.
Comes only in white
Made with polystyrene plastic
Creates lattice pie top crust
Easy to use
- BrandFox Run
- Weight 3.2 ounces
For a professional touch to your pies and pastries, the brand Ateco provides this six wheel stainless steel cutter that cuts the perfect shapes out of your dough thanks to it adjustability and expandability. This product will create even strips of dough in a matter of seconds and can be locked to ensure precision and accuracy.
With over one hundred years of experience designing and creating kitchen tools, Ateco does not hold back on quality when creating this product from stainless steel which is easy to wash and very durable. Although by far the most expensive product on our list, customers who have used this stainless steel cutter find it to be well worth it. Professionals and amateurs love the Ateco 6 Wheel Stainless Steel Cutter, whether it is being used for pies, puff pastry and all other types of deserts.
6 wheel expandable cutter
Equipped with a locking device
Made with stainless steel
- Weight 1 pounds
This next set of four pie crust cutters are of different colors and each create a unique leaf shape, making it a go-to fall leaf pie crust cutter. The Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters is designed to grant you convenience when it comes to pie decorating; in only a few seconds your pie can go from ordinary to impressive. With this crust cutter and decorator, you can create, maple, oak, double or basic leaf shapes. Once finished, you can simply throw the cutters in the dishwasher. It can be safely be safely washed and dried thanks to its durable construction.
No doubt, this product has found its way into the hearts of many bakers, thanks to its build and the results it produces with each plunge. We also love it as it is relatively inexpensive, and is a tremendous addition to an already delicious pie or cookie.
Made of Durable plastic
4 leaf cutter set
Easy to use and wash(dishwasher friendly)
Creates simple yet beautiful shapes
- Weight 1.6 ounces
To finish off our list we present to you this pastry wheel cutter from the brand Talisman Designs. It is a versatile, safe, easy and practical device that can serve to upgrade your pies and pastry and even cut out some home made pasta into strips. This brand in line with all its other products, works to make this product as easy to use as possible; all you have to do is roll the wheel over your dough and perfect 3/4 inch strips are created every time. The Talisman Designs Pastry Wheel Cutter, Beautiful Lattice Pie Crust can also be taken apart and placed in a dishwasher for cleaning making it even more convenient.
Made with BPA Free silicone plastic
Wheel cuts out perfect strips
- BrandTalisman Designs
- Weight 1.44 ounces
Best Pie Crust Cutter Buying Guide and FAQ
Types Of Pie Crust Cutters
- The Wheel
These cutters are shaped as wheels which have razors attached them and by running them over the length of the pie, you achieve a perfect cut. Although it sounds fairly basic, it does not have to be, these wheels can be designed to cut different shapes into the dough and can also be used to manually do the same. Also, they are often more versatile, as they allow bakers to cut out different shapes into their pastry, rather than a specific, confined shape like in other pie crust cutters.
- The Plunger
As the name implies, this next plunger works when you plunge it into the dough to effectively create the shape of the design of the cutter. Plungers are often made with flexible plastic or silicone and are a very easy solution to pie decorating. Depending on your purchase, plungers are available in almost every shape you can think of; it will just take a little bit of searching. Overall, these are very easy products to use and are perfect for beginners, as they can create professional looking pastries in no time at all.
- Stainless Steel Cutters
These are the more traditional cutters and are ,of course, made of stainless steel. They also come in many different shapes and sizes and easily double over as cookie cutters. What’s more, Stainless Steel cutters are often the most inexpensive of cutters but still work like a charm.
Uses Of A Pie Crust Cutter
- Decorate: This is often a given with cutters as they will be designed just for this purpose. Pie crust cutters come in different shapes and sizes and allow for an easy transfer of those beautiful shapes onto your canvas.
- Cut: This is also a given with cutters, especially thanks to the name, but it is still a use. When you need to very simply cut into your dough, you can use cutter wheels and if you are cutting the dough in order to create a shape, then shaped cutters will do the trick.
- Emboss: This essentially means to stamp a design into the dough. Making your pie unique to fit into the season does not need to be difficult. Plunger cutters will very easily emboss a beautiful shape onto the top of your pie for the extra finishing touch.
Best Pie Crust Cutter FAQ:
Q: How do you shape the edges of Pie crust?
A: If you’re using a pie crust cutter or decorator, shaping the edges of your pie can be as easy as running the the device along the edges. Many brands will provide products that are specific to edge decoration so that you won’t have to crack your brain trying to figure things out. However, if you do intend to use your hands, this can be tricky for beginners, but it is still possible. No doubt, it will ultimately depend on the shape you want to achieve.
Q: Are plastic or Metal pie crust cutters better?
A: This will really depend on your intentions when it comes to the device ad what you ultimately prefer to use, other than that neither of them is better than the other. Both types of pie crust cutters will serve their purpose although plastic cutters are often not suitable for ovens and metal cutters tend to be cheaper. Plastic is often much easier to use and a more modern device that adds convenience to your work.
Q: What Can I use if I don't have a pie crust cutter?
A: Before pie crust cutters were widely available to use many cooks and bakers relied on their own hands and creatively. Use a knife to cut delicate strips and shapes out of the pie or, safe and clean objects found around the kitchen that may be able to give you your desired shape.
Our Top Pick
Our top pick, Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters, won our favor and that of many customers for various reasons which include, affordability and variety. If you’re preparing for the holidays, this will be the only pie crust cutting set you will need thanks to the shapes it provides. This product is also made of great quality and safe material which, is in turn, easy to clean and store until the next time they need to be used. Ultimately, customers are hardly ever disappointed with this product, and we don't doubt that they will become a holiday favorite for you.