The Best Pie Dishes (Review) in 2020
Pie dishes are one of the major secrets to a great pie recipe. They are kitchen accessories designed to help the baking of pies a more efficient task within the precise recipe time. The results when the pie comes out of your oven is a crisp, evenly browned crust, filled with a well-cooked and perfect filling for your satisfaction. Every slice of your pie can be lifted right out of the pan, in perfectly beautiful wedges. This article lists ten of the most highly-rated and best pie dishes in the market today, to help you find the right pie plate for your kitchen. Each pie dish has been tested with different pie recipes to check their functionality and durability. The model enlisted also come at affordable prices that your pocket will love.
9-inch pie dish made of high-fired French Burgundy clay
Oven-safe up to 520 degrees Fahrenheit
Scratch-resistant and durable hard glazed ceramic
Resistant to thermal shocks
6-inch, 1.5-inch deep pie plates
Oven-safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
Seamless, odor-resistant, nonreactive glass
Premium-quality tempered glass construction
10-inch diameter, 0.5-inch deep pie pan
Safe-Seal anodized aluminum construction
Nonreactive, odor-resistant surface
The Best Pie Dish
Do your pies proud with the Emile Henry Classics Pie Dish. It is available in a sleek rouge red color which blends perfectly into any kitchen design and theme. This pie dish is a modern dish manufactured by the French company from all-natural materials. Since their inception in 1850, Emile Henry has sought to create some of the best kitchen tools and accessories, using only the best, natural materials for the safety of their customers. This modern pie dish is constructed from a high-fired burgundy clay thus is coming with high resistance to breakages and damage.
The Emile Henry pie dish offers the best heat retention in the market today. It also provides superior and even-heat diffusion, which helps to keep all meals prepared hot for longer. You can make use of your pie dish in the grill, oven and even your microwave, without any damage issues. Also, this unit can go directly from the refrigerator or freezer to a table or hot oven depending on your preference. Make a pie daily with your new pie dish from Emile Henry and clean it with ease within a short period. To keep this unit safe from scratches and crazing, it features a tough glaze.
To keep this pie dish clean, you only need to use soap and warm water. All products indeed lose their strength and rigidity with time, but this dish from Emile Henry is operational for up to ten years before it begins to experience any manufacturing defects. We love the beauty and excellent performance of this pie dish, and we want everyone to experience it too.
Made in France
Superior heat retention
Pyrex bowls and containers are commonplace in many household kitchens, as they’re used for a wide array of meals and tasks. The Pyrex brand has taken these tools and accessories a step further by redesigning them with a touch of modernism and innovation. The first of many models launched by the company on our list is the Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Pie Plate. This pie dish is manufactured in the USA by some of the most careful hands in the industry. It comes as a dual set which includes two distinct and highly efficient pie plates for your different recipes.
The Pyrex pie plates are designed and built from non-porous Pyrex glass which can be used in any dishwasher, microwave and oven of your choice, depending on what you wish to create. After cooking, you can keep your meal inside the plate and store it in your refrigerator for the next day. The Pyrex Easy Grab plate doesn’t absorb any flavors or odors from your foods, thanks to the non-porous nature of the unit. This also means that the dishes do not get stained fast. Every plate designed by the Pyrex brand comes with a two-year limited warranty against any manufacturer defect, which shows how confident the company is about the quality in the design of their products.
Enjoy your crispy pie crust, created with support from this fantastic Pyrex Glass Pie Plate. It is the perfect addition to a kitchen, thanks to its incredible versatility which enables you to prepare and serve your dishes in one container. Reduce the kitchen mess with this pie plate and join the generation of bakers and cooks all across the world.
Made in the USA
2-year limited warranty
We love the Pyrex brand because they understand the demands and needs of their customers. We spoke, and they listened, designing to meet every problem experienced with other competing brands. Their solution is the form of the Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate. This is yet another best pie plate creation of theirs, made from the same non-porous, Pyrex glass all their other products are designed with. This material is chosen such that the bowl doesn’t absorb any flavor, stain, or odor from your meals.
With the convenient design of this unit, you can cook and serve from your Pyrex pie plate immediately it comes out of the oven. Such versatility in use reduces your overall kitchen mess and makes the kitchen a more enjoyable space.
The Pyrex Bakeware plate is similar to other Pyrex products, with the distinct feature being its usage. By design, you can use the Bakeware pie plate to make all your casseroles, pieces of bread, lasagnas, pies, cakes, and cobblers. It is a proud American product made with a two-year warranty that is greater than what’s offered by several brands in the market today. The Pyrex Bakeware pie plate is the best baking dish recommended by culinary experts and food lovers. It is found on various pie dish reviews as the best unit with high durability and better functionality. We can guarantee that investment in this brand will enable you to have the best pies and casserole dishes you have ever tasted. As an option, you can also get this unit for your friends, and any other loved one with a desire to create delicious pies.
Convenient glass structure
Proudly made in the USA
Two years limited warranty
OXO Good Grips Pie Plate is the best pie pan in the business today. It is created by a veteran brand, which has decades of manufacturing experience at their fingertips. OXO understands the needs and demands of their clients; thus, they design to suit them all. Their ability to launch highly versatile products made from the best natural materials makes them a brand worth knowing, which is why we recommend their Good Grips Glass Pie Plate.
All across the world, different families make use of this plate because it delivers on its promise of being functional and durable. The Good Grips plates are made from thermal-shock-resistant materials, under careful surveillance to ensure that it is the highest quality.
This mini pie pans features the use of borosilicate glass that can withstand different temperatures from your oven to the refrigerator. It can also be used in your microwave without the fear of it experiencing cracks. We love that this plate has an easy to read dimension marking, as this helps us create the perfect tasting recipes for family and friends. It caters for ergonomics and comfort via its easy-grip system and generous rim design. You can make all your quiches, cakes, pies, and crumbles in this unit freely and enjoy their taste void of any metals are material from the plate. After cooking, cleaning is essential to maintain the durability and also for health purposes. The cleaning process for this pie plate is straightforward, as it requires only the use of warm water and dish soap. Experience quality from OXO with this plate and make all your picnics and meals more enjoyable.
Thermal-shock-resistant borosilicate glass
Easy-read 9-in Dimension marking
Perfect for crumbles
Many of us might have come across product manufactured with cast iron. We can, therefore, attest to the materials durability and longevity as well as how easy it is to carry around. With such a premise, we present to you the Cast Iron Pie Pan. We are aware that it is every cooks dream to show their family with pies that have golden brown crusts and juicy fillings, even without the use of regular plates. We all wish to reduce the number of dishes we clean after the cooking process; thus; we are always on the lookout for multifunctional cooking utensils.
With this cast iron pie pan, your problems have been solved. This Cast Iron unit features a decorative yet durable construction.
It possesses all the necessary features of a mini pie pans. This cast iron unit has a diameter of 10” and features decorative handles that offer convenient handling at all times. It allows you to bake all your delectable pies to perfection, with a smaller amount of time and fewer utensils. The pie pan features the use of an actual seasoned finished cast iron, an affordable rate that many homes can pay for and extended durability for you and generations to come. Make use of the Cast Iron Pie Pan and enjoy your fluffy rolls and cakes. You can get this unit for all culinary creatives and homeowners with the desire to create more pie dishes.
True Seasoned Finished cast iron
Decorative molded cast iron handles
The perfect addition to your kitchen
Bake delectable pies
The Anchor Hocking Oven is a mini pie plate designed by a leading manufacturer in the culinary industry. This is one fantastic ceramic pie dish that offers to make your pie preparations more exciting and less stressful. From oven to table or even to your refrigerator, this unit promises to be highly functional, to offer you immense value for money. The editorial loves this product because it is designed in the classic pie dish shape.
It maintains all sentimental value of the original design and merges new innovative features and elements which keep it abreast with our ever-evolving product design industry. The Anchor pie plate is well suited for all your desserts and small pies. It can be used by all culinary creatives and even those seeking to learn the art of baking.
Anchors pie plates have a seamless design and are made from tempered glass to reduce their ability to break. They come with handles that are easy to grip, which makes handling and moving them relatively easy. The use of tempered glass is also done to ensure that the unit bakes its contents evenly as compared to metal pie plates. Apart from the oven, you can also place this product in your microwave, freezer, and dishwasher as it doesn’t pose any risks or experience any damages. We are confident in the functionality and durability of this product. We know that its non-reactive glass construction prevents the absorption of stains, smells, and flavors from your meals. Enjoy this all American product and experience the brand’s ingenuity and robust product design.
From tempered glass
Non-reactive glass construction
Another well-designed bakeware we are proud to include in our recommendations list is the Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware. This is yet another mini pie pan designed for use in most households by all cooking enthusiasts. It comes with a 5-inch diameter and is built from the heavy-gauge steel core system. The use of steel is to enhance its durability, and also to ensure that heat is evenly distributed when cooking. The even distribution eliminates the chances of hot spots in your delicious cakes and cookies, and this results in all your meals being smoothly and perfectly browned.
To deliver long-lasting and high-quality performance to customers. The Calphalon brand designed the interior of this deep dish pie pan with interlocking non-stick layers. This feature is also known to release twice the cooking benefits of the plates predecessor, the Calphalon Classic Bakeware.
This is the most practical and beautiful pie plate in the market. It allows you to create all your favorite savory meat pies and dessert pies, thanks to its individuals serving pans. You can also use them as serving plates for visitors to reduce the dirty dishes you will have to wash. The Calphalon pie plates have a full lifetime warranty that guarantees the brands confidence in their product. It is oven safe.
Heavy-gauge steel core
Interlocking non-stick layers
Nonstick finish is beautiful and practical.
Be a good cook now and always by getting the Good Cook Bradshaw Ceramic Pie Plate. We move away slowly from Pyrex and tempered glass into the world of ceramics where heat retention for even cooking is assured. This is the best ceramic pie plate designed by the best company in the baking sector. The Bradshaw ceramic pie plate is the best choice for many households, has it been tested for safety. This product features an oven to table design that is loved by many customers. It helps reduce your chores and also does the cooking and serving processes less stressful.
This pie plate is unique in design and function. It is made from oven-fresh ceramic and features a fully glazed exterior an even better performance.
The Bradshaw deep dish pie pan pie plate can be placed in your dishwasher, microwave, oven, and freezer. It has a cream-colored interior which makes it perfect for oven use, and it is regarded as one of the most inexpensive units available. There’s no competition between Bradshaw and other companies because they deliver more than many companies can, with little effort and a lot of confidence.
Oven to table design
USA Pan takes note of all negative comments about other brands and uses that as precedence to work on their models. This results in their products appearing as saviors to many customers and potential buyers. Their USA Pan Bakeware Pie Pan. Is one of such products. The design of this unit spells salvation in more ways than one, bringing satisfaction to all customers around the globe. We love these pie plates a lot because they are as functional as they are beautiful. These units are made from aluminized steel which is of a commercial-grade, with a heavy gauge.
The design of these pie plates features a distinct corrugated surface which allows for better air circulation for even cooking and browning of your favorite baked dishes. The plates are also coated with Americoat, which is a BPA, PTFE, and PFOA free silicone coating. The coating helps elongate the lifespan of the product to back the companies limited life-time warranty. To make this unit more sustainable and environmentally friendly, each plate is designed from recycled steel. Now you can bake more than just cakes and cookies for loved ones. You can cook more memories that every family member will remember forever.
The USA Pan brand is a member of the Bundt Family Company, which has been in existence for over five decades. They have manufactured some of the best and high-quality bakeware in the market, with every new model possessing more innovative designs and features.
Made in the USA
Unique corrugated surface design
The Fat Daddio Aluminium Pie Pan is our last and final recommendation for this article. The Fat Daddio brand is one of the leading producers of bakeware in America. They are a serious company that loves its customers as they love their profits; thus, they create well-performing items which will keep clients satisfied for longer. Their aluminum pie pan is one fantastic product made for the modern kitchen. It comes with all the necessary features of a pie dish which include the use of a heat retaining material and ergonomic handling elements.
This is a pie pan made with the ideal baking surface and from the best-anodized aluminum. It is more profound than the regular pie pans, which means more volume for your recipes.
The Fat Daddio pie plate has a non-reactive and excessively durable finish which enables the unit to cater to a broader array of baking recipes to satisfy your cravings. Rather than absorbing heat, this unit reflects heat, and this allows for even heating and the best possible rise. We know you will love the Big Daddio pie pan because it represents over five decades of determination and design expertise, with an added value of intense durability.
Flat rim design
Durable, non-reactive finish
Best Pie Dishes Buying Guide & FAQ
Things to Consider Before Purchasing a Pie Dish
Finding and selecting the best pie dishes can be frustrating when one considers all the available brands in the market. To escape the struggle of moving from brand to brand. We have listed vital factors that need to be considered before making any selection and preference.
To get a unique design on your crust, the side of your pie dish is vital. There are fluted rims or edges and those with a smoother design. The choice is more of a personal preference than any other factor; thus, choose the best side for your pies.
Size, on the other hand, is mainly dependent on how many people you will service regularly. If you have a small family and love to entertain occasionally, we advise that you invest in two sizes of pie dishes, each one catering for a different size of people. This makes the cooking process more comfortable and doesn't leave you lacking when you have several people over for dinner.
The pie dishes in today’s market are made from three significant materials, namely ceramic, glass, and metal. The choice of material depends on your preferred output for your pie dishes. If you want golden crusts, your best bet is a glass dish. Ceramic plates are better for large groups as they come in more sizes for convenience. Cast iron dishes may not appeal to everybody because they can't be used in microwaves.
- Deep Dish
Deep bowls aren't regarded as standard, but they are often asked for by many cooks and bakers. These pans are also available in different materials, with the final decision being yours to make.
Different Types of Pie Plates
- Ceramic pie dishes
The first kind we describe is the ceramic pie dish. These dishes are designed as a freezer to oven-safe pans. They offer users the best of both worlds, where their design allows them to conduct slow and even heat in a beautiful serving vessel. Ceramic dishes are generally the most expensive but also the most desired.
- Glass pie dishes
The glass pie dishes promote consistent baking and browning since the material heats at a slow and steady pace. Meals take longer to cook in these units, but the wait is worth it after tasting one slice of pie. For the perfectly baked cake and visibility into the browning of your meal, use glass pie dishes.
- Aluminum Dishes
Metal pie dishes are the most common types of pie dishes in existence. By design, they are also the most inexpensive. These dishes are made of coated aluminum with sturdy and rugged construction. They are light in weight and can heat and cool quickly. If you're into par-baking and blind baking, aluminum, and metal pie plates, in general, are your best bet.
Best Pie Dishes FAQ:
Q: Are glass or metal pie pans better?
A: The choice between glass and metal pie pans is mostly determinant on your preference as well as your intended use. For those seeing even baking within a shorter period, we will recommend the use of glass pie pans. Metal pie dishes are those that are designed for relatively more extended cooking periods since the heat takes a while to be distributed.
Q: Which cooks faster glass or metal?
A: Glass is preferred by many culinary experts when baking because it ensures the heat is distributed evenly, as compared to metal pie dishes. Metal dishes can hold heat, but they can't circulate it all around the container for thorough usage and perfect baking. If you wish to purchase a glass pie dish, we recommend those made with Pyrex glass and tempered glass, as these units don't break easily.
Q: Should I grease a pie dish?
A: While some pie dishes may require greasing, others might not. The solution is to identify the units that need greasing by reading through their specifications. Doing this will prevent you from having cake bits sticking to the bottom of your dish or pan during the baking process.
Our Top Pick
The Emile Henry Pie Dish is our top choice product in this article. Not only does this dish bake your casseroles and cakes evenly, but it also allows you to dish them and eat them out of the plate. It features a heavy-duty construction which ensures its durability at all times. The Emile Henry brand is a French-owned company with many years of experience. This company loves to create a new and innovative product which still possess sentimental values of their original design for a better output. We recommend this unit for those who like fewer chores and crispy pie crusts.
- Apple pie - BBC Good Food